Minthara non lethal weapons.

Minthara non lethal weapons Jan 9, 2024 · Afterward, you will still have to fight her and knock her out in non-lethal mode. Steal something from her so she is Temporarily Hostile. After knocking her out, kill the other goblins in the room. - Minthara: Non-lethal her counts as a pure With minthara, having her knocked out is sufficient to complete that quest. Toggle Non-Lethal Attacks is a common toggleable passive feature that allows users to knock targets out instead of killing them. This will immediately lead into combat, and it's imperative that Minthara has the 'Temporarily Hostile' status. The problem is, despite having toggled Non-Lethal on, she keeps dying on the final hit. Knocking her out will now cause her to wake up, and you will find her in Act 2 speaking to Kethric about her failing her tasks. My next step is to use Sazza to get in, until Minthara, knock her out (so I can recruit her later) and then turning the Goblin Camp into the next Atlantis Jul 27, 2024 · I'm on my 5th run and I wanted to recruit Minthara while also saving the Grove by turning her into "Temporary Hostile" and knocking her out by going melee but she just dies and her body disappears on the spot with a "Poof!" I've tried changing my weapons with basic ones (no bonus additions, no magical weapons, etc), I've tried just beating her up bare hands, I've been trying throwing her So non lethal is weird, I hope someone makes a full write up of it at some point but basically some NPCs will wake up after a long rest if you knock them out but others usually are classed as dead. Just remember, non-lethal only works if you’re attacking her physically, so steer clear of spells and ranged attacks. Kill the other goblins in the room, then kill Razlin Go back to Haslin and tell him you killed the leadership. The key to getting Minthara in a good run is to beat the shit out of her first. This is very crucial only to knock her out and not kill her with the attacks. No Aug 17, 2023 · There's one companion you have to KO (Minsc) and now it seems, another (Minthara). Is some sort of bug or this will this allow me to find it laterer? Under "passives" you can toggle on/off non-lethal attacks. Their patrols are also trained to be as stealthy as possible. Switch to Non-Lethal Mode for your weapons. Im 100% sure I toggled non-lethal on Karlachs turn before hitting Minthara with Shadowhearts Spiritual Weapon. Sep 17, 2023 · Honestly you should just be able to use non-lethal attacks to render Minthara unconscious and have it count toward saving the Grove, so she shows up later in Moonrise. Simply ensure that the last hit during the fight against her is a non-lethal one and knocks her unconscious. You will know if you succeeded as she will be on trial at Moonrise Towers. Just make sure that you have non-lethal toggled on in the passives tab, and that whoever gets the 'killing' blow does so with a melee weapon only. So I'm there and I give my Tav druid flame blade and put non-lethal attacks and BOOM - kills really bummed out bout all this :/. No Usefull info since I was planning on knocking out Minthara in my current run. Do not use arrows or spells!!! Non lethal can be finicky especially if you're using weapons and other equipment that have damage riders that ignore non lethal. If you have proficiency, equip in main hand to gain: Pommel Strike Make a non-lethal attack against an enemy and possibly Daze them. And no if you kill Minthara in act 1 you can’t resurrect her sadly. Something else to know: don't use poison or bleed or other DOTs on unconscious enemies as the damage will still kill them anyway. Use non-lethal melee attacks on Minthara. already have 2 more infernal alloy but no Aug 6, 2023 · Non-lethal attacks were a bit funky during early access, and it doesn't look to have improved with Baldur's Gate 3 version 1. Can you have Karlach and Minthara at the same time? With no mods and I have Karlach, Minthara and Wyll. When you get to Minthara, make sure you enable 'Non-Lethal' attacks. This requires you to use non-lethal attacks—a setting you can toggle at any time in your Passives menu as long as you’re using melee weapons. Minthara will lie on the ground, you can undress her >=), I didn't and I headed to the camp I took a long rest and when I got back to the ground, not ALL of her equipment was dropped Not sure why this is happening, but I have accidently killed Minsc and Minthara with Lae'zel while non-lethal damage is toggled on. Jul 24, 2023 · To recruit Minthara, players must activate non-lethal attacks and knock her out during their encounter, rather than killing her. Ranged and Magic cannot do non lethal. Pretty sure you need the "temporarily hostile" condition -- you definitely do for Minthara, not sure about Sazza. Jun 28, 2023 · This requires you to use non-lethal attacks—a setting you can toggle at any time in your Passives menu as long as you’re using melee weapons. 3. Sep 17, 2023 · non-lethal only works with melee weapons. Dec 31, 2023 · Looking to recruit Minthara without questioning your own morality in Baldur's Gate 3? Here is a guide to help! The problem is if your weapon attack deals ANY additional damage besides normal weapon damage (any additional elemental damages, sneak attack, caustic ring, etc. For example, if you deal fire damage in the final blow, target’s body would end up burnt, or Disintegrate deals force damage but the body would turn to dust. Defeated her, made sure that she was flagged as “knocked out (temporary). Then reach Act 2, and you can find her alive in Moonrise Towers, judged by General Ketheric Thorn during Act 2. May 15, 2025 · To recruit her, you must side with goblins, or knock her out with a non-lethal hit. or hit her with a ranged attack - ranged attacks are not non-lethal. Then go to Minthara. There, you can knock her out in non-lethal mode. Long rest. Strangely, this counts as you killing Minthara for the goblin leaders quest, so you can carry on as normal. It’s similar to the former workaround that I mentioned, but with far fewer steps. Magic, ranged attacks, and damage over time effects can still be lethal. This is a decent buff to damage, but it comes at the cost of a high-level spell slot and concentration. Jan 3, 2025 · To get to that point, though, you'll need to be in the Goblin Camp and working through the battles with the various Goblin leaders. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Just remember to use non-lethal attacks during her battles. Mar 25, 2024 · i am trying to avoid killing minthara (the drow in the goblin camp) but no matter what i use as my "last hit" while having none lethal on, it still kills her, is this like a know bug or am i doing something wrong here? Can you keep Minthara alive? To do this, you'll have to attack the Goblin Camp like normal, but instead of killing Minthara, you must knock her out. Unless they are getting ready to engage in open warfare, and by that I mean massive army vs massive army, light and medium armor is the norm. 0. Ranged weapons and spells don’t work, you have to knock her out with melee or risk killing her. I went into goblin camp, happened to murder everyone and left Minthara's room for last. Once Sazza is downed on the opposite side of the bridge to Minty, shoot out the bridge; you’ll understand why later. Made sure to hit her only with melee attacks (non-lethal only works in melee, not with ranged weapons or spells of any kind). Freed Halsin and defeated the rest of the goblin camp. Magic and ranged attacks won’t work for this, so stick to melee hits. However on the the second question can it be different. I believe I actually killed the other two leaders (HP points to 0). Then you can Jul 2, 2024 · So, when you are going to fight Minthara ( lethal or non-lethal doesn't matter, you still have to defeat her one way or another if you want Dammon's stuff later ) here are some tips for non-lethal cuz i like to have them all in my team and i find it interesting and extra challenging for solo honor run especially for spell casting builds. You can have added damage from force, fire, if those are weapon properties. But I didn't have any optiona for non lethal attacks? So I got minthara down to like 2HP and then hit her over the head with a shovel via "improvised melee weapon". The game counts every non-lethal as a kill: - Miriam brothers: When you approach the Hag and tell Miriam that her brothers are alive but knocked out she starts yelling that everyone is dead. Steal the Idol. This subreddit is not "official" (there isn't an "official" subreddit), and is ran by player volunteers. Again, don’t kill her once knocked out. Rather than killing Minthara as you would normally do by helping the Grove, you can instead select the non-lethal combat option, and when Minthara drops to 1 HP, she will be knocked out. Engage in combat with Minthara as a temporary hostile, this can be done by attacking her or stealing in front of her, defeat her using non-lethal damage. The most prudent approach is to instruct all your characters to switch to melee weapons with non-lethal attacks activated and engage Minthara. Make sure she's temporarily hostile (attack unprompted or pickpocket/steal in front of her) and deal with her BEFORE you free Halsin. This way, you can still avoid alerting the whole Goblin Camp. All you have to do is turn on non-lethal damage in your Passives tab and fight her while you're taking out the other two leaders. But it should. Feb 2, 2024 · Non-lethal attacks are exclusive to melee attacks; magic cannot achieve this effect. She respects those with the strength to follow their own will, and enjoys cruel irony on occasion. You'll find the reason why minthara can't even join even when you only knocked her out when you reached moonrise tower that is basically all those failed their mission is to be executed and if you save the groove that means minthara is executed Once in combat you must knock her out by toggling Non-Lethal Attacks in the passives tab without killing the goblin guards around her to avoid the Witness condition. No biggie, I killed everyone outside and went back in for her, I remembered to break a torch (apparently her favorite, had sentimental value and everything) to aggro her and then switch the passive on. Then, long rest and she will revive (thanks to the temp hostile tag). Turn on non lethal damage and knock her out. Jan 21, 2021 · Lethal vs Non-Lethal Self Defense Weapons. Knock her out instead of killing her by toggling the non-lethal options on. Best BG3 Minthara Build. ) the non-lethal damage isn't gonna do anything Non lethal attacks only work with melee attacks (your fist or weapon at hand) doesn’t work with arrows, thrown objects or magic. The default for KOing a perm-hostile enemy is that the game still treats them as dead. That way I only aggro Minthara's group. Ranged and Magic attacks will not count as Non-Lethal even if you have Non-Lethal turned on. I was hoping doing a non-lethal defeat of Minthara during the raid on the Druid Grove would allow you to recruit her in Moonrise Towers. She can show up in Moonrise exactly as she does if you just skip over the conflict, being punished for her failures. Nov 30, 2023 · Then I went downstairs and rescued Halsin, came up, killeed priestess Gut, switched to non lethal damage to knock Minthara out during the ensuing fight, then killed Dror Ragzlin last. Aug 15, 2023 · How about no? Plot-wise you have to choose between her or halsin, no other way. Jul 3, 2024 · To me it happens inconsistently if I side with goblins, delve into fears and fail persuasion checks with Minthara so that she forces me to non-lethal knock out at camp when ganged up by goblins in the camp, so once I reached the prison area I had to do the dice checks during rescue with disadvantage as we were not flagged into a relationship by only melee attacks work with non-lethal, so arrows/spells/etc are out. Nor is there a range constraint. Once Minthara’s hit points reach zero, she will be knocked unconscious. Great weapon fighting will be her best despite non-lethal attacks, the added fire damage is still lethal. Jul 3, 2024 · To me it happens inconsistently if I side with goblins, delve into fears and fail persuasion checks with Minthara so that she forces me to non-lethal knock out at camp when ganged up by goblins in the camp, so once I reached the prison area I had to do the dice checks during rescue with disadvantage as we were not flagged into a relationship by I only know about three points in the entire game where toggling non-lethal attacks actually changes something: - knocking out Minthara to recruit her later - knocking out Sazza in the goblin camp to encounter her later (you also need to knock out Minthara) - knocking out Minsc to recruit him in Act 3 So is there anything else? Jan 2, 2024 · Attack her, but ensure that your non-lethal passive is enabled, this way, you can defeat Minthara and complete your quest, but she'll still be alive to recruit later. Also, if you're using the tadpoles, make sure cull the weak is off! Once you've knocked her out, if you hover over her, instead of 'dead', it should say 'knocked out (temporary)' under her health bar. Actually, Scratch that. I know she has to be temporarily hostile, and I can't Long Rest, and I've mostly done that. It must be melee weapons doing the nonlethal damage. 2. This means that if you initiated combat with her through dialogue, as opposed to committing a crime within her vision cone, she will be marked as dead regardless of whether or not you chose to defeat her non-lethally. 3) Do Halsin and Minthara have a different tent or the "shared" tent is still a thing? Can you keep Minthara alive? To do this, you'll have to attack the Goblin Camp like normal, but instead of killing Minthara, you must knock her out. So Patch 5 now allows us to get Minthara legitimately (no polymorph required) via knocking her unconscious with non-lethal attacks in Act 1. I think this option should be patched-in and it wouldn't require any additional dialog: She's still gets punished by Ketheric for failing to get the artifact & how the raid May 15, 2025 · Magic Weapon: Infuse a weapon with arcane energy. Weapon actions . banging the war drum turns all nearby things in the camp hostile. Toggling on/off will apply to the entire party. I’d love the mod regardless. Dec 23, 2023 · Recruiting Minthara didn't work. Spell and arrows etc will still kill, although there is very little difference as KO'd people are removed at next long rest any way I used melee weapons. Nov 3, 2023 · This requires you to use non-lethal attacks—a setting you can toggle at any time in your Passives menu as long as you’re using melee weapons. Apr 19, 2024 · Later in the game you need non lethal weapons again when you need to capture Minsc. In both cases, use non-lethal, and she'll show up in Moonrise in Act II and can be recruited. The weapon becomes magical, receiving a +1 bonus to Attack and Damage Rolls. Knocking out Minthara and Sazza, using non-lethal melee damage, in the room Minthara is working in just as they're about to leave to attack the Grove (but before they actually go anywhere) worked beautifully for me -- both Minthara and Sazza showed up at Moonrise and acted like I Jul 8, 2023 · Toggle Non-Lethal Attacks option on. Many Americans own guns, and I definitely won’t ever discount the deterrence and stopping power in a self defense scenario of a firearm in the hands of a trained and responsible individual. Here’s how players can get Minthara on their side. This way, she’ll survive to Act 2, where you can recruit her into your party. She fell to a blow from Lae'zel with non-lethal toggled on. Minthara must be marked as temporarily hostile in order for her to appear at moonrise tower. A place to discuss Neverwinter, a free action MMORPG based on the acclaimed Dungeons & Dragons fantasy roleplaying game. Note that non-lethal only works on melee. If you are interested in more news about Baldur’s Gate 3, read also: Aug 8, 2023 · so im trying to get minthara without losing karlach steps i did was not killing her at goblin camp (didnt even speak to her) killed other leaders the druid guy still sits in goblin camp waiting for me i guess moved to act 2 which means all refuges left the grove now im at the last light inn - but Dammon not there! and no way to continue karlach story. This does not work. - The Hag pawns (the masks): if you knock them out they will disappear after a long rest. If you do this Minthara will appear in the Moonrise Towers Throne Room in Act 2 trying to explain her failures to the General Thorme. This requires you to use non-lethal attacks—a setting you can toggle at any time in your Passives menu as long as you're using melee weapons. Dec 3, 2024 · However, instead of killing her, you must knock her out using non-lethal attacks. Then all 3 focus down Minthara passively; you can somewhat hide around the corner by Minty from the goblin attacks. I knocked out Minthara in Shattered Sanctum whilst she was TEMPORARILY HOSTILE. they let one of the goblins near her bang on the war drum while fighting her. You can also talk to Minthara in the Goblin Camp and tell her to head to the Tiefling Camp. My best guess is that it is due to the Lightning Charges generated by The Sparkle Hands gloves. Apr 12, 2025 · No worries, you didn’t make a mistake killing her! Most folks end up siding with Minthara if they take an evil path and want her as a companion. Apr 13, 2023 · To do this, you’ll have to attack the Goblin Camp like normal, but instead of killing Minthara, you must knock her out. Another way to make Minthara survive is to steal the idol from the ritual in the Shattered Sanctum. While this passive is turned on, when an Unarmed Strike or melee weapon attack reduces a creatures hit points to zero or one, it will become Knocked OutKnocked Out or In the fight with her make sure you toggle on non-lethal attacks (remember only physical melee attacks can be non-lethal, also you just have to finish her off with non-lethal so you can use magic against her just don't kill her with it), this will knock her out instead of killing her, but for the purposes of the quest to kill the goblin leaders she still counts as "dead. Minthara does not view Sazza as an ally (similar to the orb). Apr 20, 2025 · Non-lethal only works with melee attacks, so you need to make sure your last hit is a melee attack with the non-lethal option enabled. Checked that Minthara was temporarily hostile throughout the fight. A drow elf wielding this weapon deals an additional 1d4 Poison against restrained targets. After knocking her out you may kill the rest of the goblin camp while avoiding using Long Rests and Fast Traveling. Baldur's Gate 3 Guides - Is there a way to keep Minthara alive? To do this, you'll have to attack the Goblin Camp like normal, but instead of killing Minthara, you must knock her out. Nevertheless, if you want to check it yourselves, don’t forget to change your weapon mode on non-lethal. Hey all, I'm trying to knock out Minthara. - Minthara: Non-lethal her counts as a pure Edit: TLDR: Yes it is possible to recruit Minthara in Patch 5 without killing the tieflings in act one. The main reason to not use 'non-lethal' mechanically, is that abilities that trigger on kills (great weapon master feat for example), do not trigger on knock out. Don't talk to her. Make sure she's temporarily hostile. Dec 7, 2023 · Baldur’s Gate 3 now lets players recruit Minthara, without having to betray the whole Grove. Rescue her, and she will join you. Attack her/commit a crime. If you toggled 'Non-lethal attacks' because you wanted to save her that way, it assumes she just dies, and the game treats you like that (approval drop from Jaheira and lootable 'corpse' Key takeaway: Keep attacking her lethally to get a non-lethal resolution possibility Oct 12, 2020 · Patch 5 allows players to recruit Minthara and Halsin. Look for the icon that shows a figure getting whacked on the head with a hammer . I assume Minthara is one of the ones that just classes as dead. Also if you non-lethally KO people in EA they just disappear eventually, not sure if it'll have more story implications in the full game. Remember toggle the Non-Lethal Attacks off after knocking So, when you are going to fight Minthara ( lethal or non-lethal doesn't matter, you still have to defeat her one way or another if you want Dammon's stuff later ) here are some tips for non-lethal cuz i like to have them all in my team and i find it interesting and extra challenging for solo honor run especially for spell casting builds. Things might have changed How to Recruit Minthara Without Attacking the Grove in Baldur Oct 13, 2023 · The Auntie Ethel questline is only one among many instances where non-lethal damage leads to frustrating results. ) May 30, 2019 · With Minthara already knocked out she'll be safe. Don't hit her with missile weapons or stuff that does DoT like poison or burning. You'll have to carefully lethal the person and get them close to death then unequip gear with damage riders that ignore non lethal, including weapons that have additional non melee damage like psychic, force etc It's not an issue of forgetting to turn on non-lethal. Drow from Menzoberranzan are trained for dual wielding fighting (and dual wielding non-finesse weapons specifically). It still fits in with her failing to claim hold of the Astral Prism and eliminate the Grove (in-fact more fitting because she obviously failed in this case). All you need to do is turn on Non-Lethal Damage when you fight Minthara. If Minthara's health reaches zero due to magical damage, she will perish directly. Commit a crime in front of Minthara. How to create a powerful Paladin build for Minthara in Baldur's Gate 3 - Best equipment, abilities & spells. You will then have the opportunity to recruit her in Act 2. The main to use it, is if you want that person to not die. Thus why I recommend using 2 melee attackers on Minthara. Aug 24, 2023 · It makes no difference except for a very few NPCs, and generally the game will try to prompt you with someone asking you to subdue them, and in EA there were a couple enemies that had surrender dialogue when they fell below certain HP and non-lethal attacks could also be used to get them to surrender without killing them by accident. But im not sure how exactly. She’ll be available later for sure! QuestMaster87 - May 8, 2025 So playing honour mode and got to the goblin camp and eventually to minthara and I wanted to knock her out so I can save her in moonrise towers. Might as well have just killed them. Mar 25, 2024 · Non-lethal attacks are restricted to be from melee attacks, but it is notably not restricted specifically to melee weapon attacks; melee spell attacks are permitted. No further influence. Bide for the right moment and step forward your fire giantess <3 and hammer Minthara at 14HP with the non-lethal attack. But non lethal attacks for some reason is a 50/50 with story based characters most of the time they don’t work, meaning they just die after you long rest. Just making this post so other people can know about it. How do I avoid killing Minthara? Toggle Non-Lethal Attacks on and beat Minthara until she goes down. Feb 3, 2024 · Minthara dying to non lethal attacks I've just been trying to take minthara down with non lethal attacks. Fists are fine, too. When you reach Moonrise Tower in Act 2, you'll see Minthara being interrogated and judged by Ketheric Thorm and Z'rell. To toggle Non-Lethal Attacks on and off, go to the Passives section of the hotbar (or expand your action radial if you're using a controller). Every goblin around her that I have to take out ends up unconscious on the ground after being taken out. [Needs Verification] Minthara dislikes shows of compassion, especially towards those she considers weak. Aug 17, 2023 · There's one companion you have to KO (Minsc) and now it seems, another (Minthara). If non-lethal attacks had more of a role than a couple of niche moments, I’d love a Green Arrow-style Boxing Glove Arrow mod for distanced knock-outs. I just got to Moonlight Towers yesterday. So far, she's been killed twice by Astarion wielding Harold. When you get to goblin camp, again do everything like normal but do not kill Dror or attack Minthara until everything else you want to do is done. they fought Dror Ragzlin while Minthara was awake. I'm playing on xbox, and the "toilet non-lethal attacks" option is on. Every time I went into her area even with just my drow Tav Every one in the area would aggro. Otherwise, the usual way to recruit her is to use non-lethal damage and knock her out instead of killing her. To get Minthara on a good playthrough, you must activate non-lethal attacks and knock her out in the goblin camp in Act 1. Minthara approves of displays of power and control, often in the form of violent, if not efficient, solutions to problems. When non-lethal attacks is turned on, make sure the final blow should be either physical damage or non-transfigured effect. When I got there I killed all the goblins and then used non-lethal attack to knock her out. This sets up a later opportunity to rescue her in Act 2 at Moonrise Towers, where she is imprisoned and can subsequently be recruited as a companion. If Minthara survives the Druid Grove assault, you will meet her again in Act 2, and she will eventually become a playable companion. How to betray Minthara? Get to Minthara's chamber in the goblin camp before freeing Halsin. Thus avoiding them being dead and triggering anything that triggers on death. So you can knock her out, then kill the other leaders, then complete the quest by talking to halsin and zevlor. ) Lacerate Slash at your target's vital points to make it Bleed. Another decent spell to add to our arsenal. Either attack Minthara at the goblin camp without talking with her first, or steal an item and make her hostile to you. Dec 1, 2023 · Because at the same time, it may be just a way to connect some loopholes in the plot (“where is Minthara if I didn’t kill her”), and not a way to recruit her. make sure it's toggled on and you can see the status on your bar, and then whack them with a weapon (make sure it doesn't deal any extra special damage like poison or multiple attacks etc) May 15, 2024 · Baldur's Gate 3 features a ton of melee weapons to equip, but in the case of these weapons, players are better off leaving them behind. After you knock her out, you can rescue her during Act 2 while you’re sneaking around Moonrise. So, when you are going to fight Minthara ( lethal or non-lethal doesn't matter, you still have to defeat her one way or another if you want Dammon's stuff later ) here are some tips for non-lethal cuz i like to have them all in my team and i find it interesting and extra challenging for solo honor run especially for spell casting builds. Baldur's Gate 3 players will want to know how to recruit Minthara and Halsin now that the two are no longer mutually exclusive. Also you CAN NOT finish the fight with magic of any kind or arrows, the last hit MUST be with a melee weapon with non-lethal turned on. Besides possibly wanting to KO some NPCs (like Duke Ravengard). Note that non-lethal only applies to melee weapons and fists. , before starting the big battle. (Recharge: Short rest. Minthara). I read the patch notes, loaded up a slightly older save and went looking for her but no Minthara anywhere in the tower. May 15, 2025 · How to Recruit Minthara on a Good Playthrough in Baldur’s Gate 3. The option can be found under under the tab for Passive abilities, where it also explains that non-lethal attacks can only be used when unarmed or using a melee weapon. But no ranged attacks. Oct 19, 2024 · If you deal more non lethal damage then HP in that one blow and you hit then you can knock somebody down. Now that Patch 5 is live, you can recruit Minthara while siding with the Grove. Don't sweat that. At goblin camp i erased every living form except Minthara who i used non lethal attacks with her, after a long rest her unconscious body is gone (all the other corpses are still there). Those can still be lethal. So archers and spellcasters must attack accordingly. This can be attacking the goblin she's speaking to or stealing something in front of her. She was a monk without any weapons equipped both times. They showed as knocked out and I was even able to partially heal them after the battle. Further, you can use non-lethal weapons or spells like Sleep or Hold person to reduce her hit points without killing her. If you ignore the grove altogether you can still keep will and karlach but in terms of karlach most of her story will be gone because the blacksmith tiefling Jun 20, 2024 · Although the feature was present during early access, it’s worth us pointing out now – Baldur’s Gate 3 has a non-lethal option you can turn on and off. I did not engage in conversation and started the fight by throwing a smokepowder bomb at her. Apr 18, 2025 · The key is to use non-lethal attacks on her. (See: Minthara situation. Dec 3, 2023 · How to Recruit Minthara Without Killing Tieflings. Now I don't have her in Moonrise Towers. Go tell Halsin you've saved the Grove. Messing with it effects all party members, and then any melee attacks (both unarmed or with a weapon) that drop a creautre to 0 hp just knocks them out. Thorn Whip uses a melee spell attack with a range of 30'. This can be done by toggling the "Non-Lethal" setting in your Passives menu when using melee weapons. One quick note about Non-Lethal attacks since you touched on it: Non-Lethal only applies to melee weapons and unarmed attacks. Just went right up to her, and hit her in the back of the head with the non-lethal side of my big two-handed sword. The other best scenarios where you must use non-lethal damage is to knock out Minthara to recruit Oct 19, 2024 · If you deal more non lethal damage then HP in that one blow and you hit then you can knock somebody down. Not realizing that Minthara would wake up. but she is still dying ? Dec 5, 2023 · During the combat, only prioritize non-lethal attacks to Minthara. And the game treats them dead. Dec 12, 2024 · Yes, to knock unconscious people, make sure you enable the passive for your characters for doing non-lethal damage. A number of relevant scenarios arise in Act 3 in particular, as the Lower City of Baldur's Gate features plenty of feuding human forces all interested in the party's involvement. I solved the Druid vs Thiefling situation by uncovering it, Karlach and Wyll are good friends now. Minthara is a powerful character in BG3. ~ Go to Minthara's room. The only benefit was for RP purposes and to avoid breaking your Oath as a Paladin. Make sure you have non lethal passive on. Command: Approach works well too. Tried doing the knock out Minthara method to recruit her. In its current state, the knockout method for Minthara is very flawed. (from character spellbook under Common) The issue with non-lethal attacks in EA was that it had no story implications, the NPC would eventually disappear from the game same as if they were killed. Most common theory is that those two are Halsin and Minthara since her goal is to wipe out the grove (Halsin's home) and his goal is to wipe out the goblin leaders (inc. Do not pick the option that says Minthara got away. But regardless of who lands the felling blow (my paladin or Karlach) when Minthara goes down she explodes covering the ground with blood and leaving no body. All good May 7, 2025 · If you’re just looking to recruit her, a non-lethal knockout is the way to go during your fight at the goblin camp. If you not use stealth then yes but if you use stealth and your successful on your stealth skill and move your character out of sight and your lucky enough they not find you find you In this guide on How To Knock People Out Non Lethal Damage In Baldurs Gate 3 we explain non lethal damage as it doesn't always work. She attacked the Grove and I turned my attacks to non lethal and she still died maybe I screwed up by shooting her with a fireball. I’d like to discuss the difference between lethal and non-lethal. (make sure you talk to Halsin!) Attack Minthara without speaking to her. And overall it is a very useful feature to not kill vendors or NPC with a storyline ( a lot of them return in act 3 if you let them live ) when you aggro them somehow. . When it comes to Minthara, let non-lethal combat work against her in Act 1. I generally immediately have someone silence or destroy the War Drum so they can't alert the whole building and do the same with the Eye. Kill Ragzlin and as many goblins as you like. A common complaint from players is how knocking a NPC unconscious Jan 30, 2024 · 1, You can only use melee weapons for nonlethal damage, as stated. If she's not, start over. I then turned on non-lethal attacks and knocked her out with a melee weapon. How do you keep Minthara alive? Use Polymorph to turn MInthara into a sheep, then cast Dominate Beast to keep her by your side. Do not long rest. Immediately turned on non-lethal passive mode. EpicGamer90$ - April 23, 2025 OHHHH, I’ve been using ranged attacks! So in patch 5 it was announced that you can recruit Minthara even without raiding the grove. You find non lethal weapons settings in the tabs above you spells/attacks, bottom screen 4 days ago · You can definitely knock Minthara unconscious instead of killing her. (Simple melee weapon) How Mar 7, 2024 · To me it happens inconsistently if I side with goblins, delve into fears and fail persuasion checks with Minthara so that she forces me to non-lethal knock out at camp when ganged up by goblins in the camp, so once I reached the prison area I had to do the dice checks during rescue with disadvantage as we were not flagged into a relationship by Feb 29, 2024 · Non-lethal damage can only be done with melee weapons like swords, clubs, maces, and hammers. " Aug 17, 2023 · Is a non-lethal approach ever acknowledged by anyone? Do characters you fought but did not kill appear again, later on? Or is a non-lethal approach technically the same as killing everyone, in terms of the story? Example: I defeated the NPCs guarding the old hag non-lethally but after the fight with the hag, nothing happened with them. She should become temporarily hostile. Dec 15, 2023 · Minthara is a recruitable Dark Elf (and evil) companion found in Act 1. Once you unlock Aura of Protection you need to activate it for its effect. That's what I did. She is a Lv 6 paladin, so be careful as she is strong with divine smite and extra attack from Lv 5. Knock her out. Knock her out (non lethal, melee weapon damage) Save. Now I had kiilled Gut and the other guy rescued Halsin and he mentioned about killing all 3 I wanted to knock out minthara with a non lethal attack but it wouldn't let me. drojrrx lefm gpsnh ediy ojfczi zghssex fxrl omyet jjjb romui